If youre waiting for Black Friday or Cyber Monday to score a big deal, theres a warning for shoppers before hitting buy now: dont assume a sale price automatically means youre saving money.
A new investigation from Groundwork Collaborative is raising questions about some of the deals advertised on Amazon during two of the biggest shopping events of the year.
The organization examined more than 350 products featured on Amazons Black Friday and Cyber Monday deal pages in 2024 and 2025.
Researchers found nearly 1 in 3 products were the same price or even cheaper during the month before the sale event. Nearly 1 in 10 were actually more expensive during the advertised sale.
One example stood out.
Groundwork Collaborative says a pair of UGG boots advertised for $179.98 on Cyber Monday had sold for just $98.40 about four weeks earlier.
That means the advertised Cyber Monday price was about 83% higher than that earlier price.
I spoke with Breyon Williams, chief economist at Groundwork Collaborative, about the findings and Amazons response to the report.
Williams acknowledged that the investigation did find legitimate savings among the products researchers reviewed.
There were genuine deals that we found in our report, Williams said. We want to make sure, though, when you are marketing deals, 100% of those deals are good for consumers.
Williams said shoppers should be able to trust that something marketed as a deal is actually saving them money.
We shouldnt say, OK, well, 75% are good, Williams said. 100% of the deals should save shoppers money.
What shoppers can do before buyingBefore making a Black Friday or Cyber Monday purchase, consumers can take a few extra steps:
Check the products price history rather than relying only on the advertised discount Compare prices at other retailers before making the purchase Look closely at the actual dollar price, not just a large percent off number If a purchase can wait, monitor the price over time to see whether the holiday sale is truly the lowest priceGroundwork Collaborative is also calling on retailers to provide shoppers with more pricing transparency. The organization wants retailers to show the lowest price a product sold for during the previous 30 days when advertising a sale.
For shoppers, the bottom line is simple: A Black Friday or Cyber Monday label doesnt necessarily mean youre getting the best price.
Taking an extra minute to check a products previous price could help you determine whether youre looking at a real bargain or just a deal that looks good on the screen.